Skip to main content
Just-Lisa-Now-
Intuit Community Champion
May 26, 2020
Question

Protecting 2016 IRSP refunds with a Protective Claim

https://mailchi.mp/taxpracticepro.com/protecting-potential-2016-isrp-refunds-with-a-protective-claim?fbclid=IwAR0l-ZYXbJXivFOMpmQVbkavlYVpZGnUwjZpaAyg9m8PQBNXxXwoKW-Rtb4

I'm not sure if I had many of these that paid the penalty for no insurance (that's what this is referring to, right?)...Id have to go digging, not sure if there's a query set up for this or not...is anyone else being proactive with this, just in case?

This topic has been closed for replies.

4 replies

May 26, 2020

I would need to re-read things, but from what I remember, the court case did NOT say that.  They said that AFTER the penalty was changed to zero, the "mandate" to have health insurance is unconstitutional.  That would have no effect on prior penalties.

There could be more litigation in the courts for further changes, but as of now, the court's ruling changed nothing about prior penalties.

sjrcpa
Level 15
June 9, 2020

@TaxGuyBillSome in the tax community feel that if Texas et al prevail in the Supreme Ct, the whole law will be thrown out. Then Net Investment Income Tax and additional Medicare tax, as well as the penalty/tax for not having insurance will be declared unconstitutional. There's a move to file protective claims for refund for 2016 .

I commented on a post about this yesterday but can't find it today using the lousy search function. Instead I found this post. Ooh  -found it in my notification feed

https://proconnect.intuit.com/community/proseries-discussions/discussion/re-has-anyone-filed-a-protective-claim-for-aca-penalty-relief/01/88233#M49074

The more I know the more I don’t know.