Welcome back! Ask questions, get answers, and join our large community of tax professionals.
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

S corp savings vs sole Prop

ptax255
Level 7

Hi, am I missing anything major with the calculations below? Sole prop looking to convert to S corp. Thanks!

 Sole PropS Corp  
Net income$111,835.00$36,835.00  
Wages$0.00$75,000.00  
SE tax deduction$7,850.00$5,738.00  
QBI Deduction$7,375.00$7,367.00  
Solo 401K deduction$43,151.00$41,250.00  
     
Income Tax$18,710.65$20,118.00  
SS+Medicare$15,699.00$11,476.00  
CA S corp tax0$2,177.53  
     
Total tax$34,409.65$33,771.53$638.12Savings
0 Cheers
24 Comments 24

CA tax is 1.5% X net income. I don't know how you get $2,177. Maybe you are not showing CA adjustments from Federal.

 

QBI deduction looks right (if there is no capital gain income.)

TaxGuyBill
Level 15

I haven't analyzed your numbers, but at first glance it looks reasonable.

Based on your numbers, I certainly hope he doesn't elect to be taxed as a S-corporation.  The costs to file the 1120-S, 941s, 940, W-2, pay unemployment, and reduced potential Social Security benefits would make the S-election seem like a bad idea.

Payroll processing costs

Legal fees for incorporation

Costs for another tax return, annually

Your fees for guidance and CAS related to reasonable compensation, health insurance, accountable plans and other S Corp matters

qbteachmt
Level 15

Agree with TGB, unless there already are employees (but you listed Solo 401(k)). Also, this affects office in home deduction, vehicle mileage allowance, meals and lodging provisions; there are some ">2% shareholder" limitations and ">10% shareholder" limitations. They already get a benefit from health care premiums (so that's a wash). If that income isn't a nice, regular, feed, then S Corp management really is difficult by comparison to SP.

*******************************
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
abctax55
Level 15

And the CA 1.5% is 'inclusive' of the $ 800.00 minimum tax, so it doesn't kick in until CA NI is more than $ 53,333.

"*******Tax software is no substitute for a professional tax preparer*******
( Generic Comment )"

The PTE deduction is another factor and might be a significant benefit.

ptax255
Level 7

Isn't $800 the minimum to be paid? Also if I'm not mistaken it's waived for first year? I'm also including as CA tax 1.1% SDI on wages.

ptax255
Level 7

Agreed. I didn't inlcude it because for 2024 election, payment had to be made by June.

ptax255
Level 7

Thank you! Fair point with home office deduction. As a sole prop it's about $22K, which wouldn't be reasonable as S corp.

0 Cheers
George4Tacks
Level 15

Also take into account how much liability insurance you can buy, without all the paperwork overhead, to get the protection you might be looking for as an S-Corp. 


Answers are easy. Questions are hard!
abctax55
Level 15

"...Also if I'm not mistaken it's waived for first year? "

Are you planning for just one year, or for multiple? 

And CA tax of $ 2177 would mean income of  $ 145,134 - which is way more than your projections show.

"*******Tax software is no substitute for a professional tax preparer*******
( Generic Comment )"
ptax255
Level 7

Multiple years, but I'm also trying to determine if client should make a retroactive 2024 election, or start in 2025. By showing 2024 savings, I think 2025 and later would be greater due to PTE (pending any tax law changes of course). Additional CA tax for 2024 then would just be 1.1% SDI.

TaxGuyBill
Level 15

@ptax255 wrote:

I'm also trying to determine if client should make a retroactive 2024 election, or start in 2025.


 

Why would the client want to do it AT ALL?    Based on your numbers, after the increased tax preparation/payroll fees and paying Unemployment, they likely will be paying MORE money.  Plus they will reduce their future potential Social Security benefits.

 

Even if it was a good idea (which at first glance it seems like a very bad idea):

  • Is this already an LLC?  Did you already factor in the CA franchise tax for the LLC?
  • What makes you think it qualifies for the late election?  You can't arbitrarily decide to make the election after the due date.
qbteachmt
Level 15

"with home office deduction. As a sole prop it's about $22K"

Whew! cough-cough. I just choked on my coffee while reading this.

*******************************
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
0 Cheers
ptax255
Level 7
Spoiler
 

That northern CA kind of mortgage, taxes etc

qbteachmt
Level 15

Point being, doesn't $22K kind of settle the issue to that side?

*******************************
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
PATAX
Level 15

Based on what you have provided and on what the others have said, it doesn't look like there's much of an advantage to change. Don't forget that S corporations that do not pay what is deemed as reasonable compensation are prone to IRS audit, which could lead to a full audit. Audits are expensive and nerve-racking to the client, even if it is eventually  a no change audit. If the client wants limited liability, can you become a sole member LLC/disregarded entity?

ptax255
Level 7

Wouldn't the amount be the same at $22k as S corp under an accountable plan?

qbteachmt
Level 15

"under an accountable plan?"

Maybe. I found this for you:

https://accountants.intuit.com/articles/home-office-deductions-expenses/

 

*******************************
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
ptax255
Level 7

Updated based on everyone's feedback. Thanks! Curious, what amount do you all think it's worth all the extra work of an S corp?

 

 Sole PropS Corp  
Net income$111,835.00$36,835.00  
Wages$0.00$75,000.00  
SE tax deduction$7,850.00$5,738.00  
QBI Deduction$7,375.00$6,681.87  
Solo 401K deduction$43,151.00$41,250.00  
CA Tax deduction $1,625.00  
PTE $3,425.66  
     
Income Tax$18,710.65$18,590.07  
SS+Medicare$15,699.00$11,476.00  
CA S corp tax0$1,625.00  
     
Total tax$34,409.65$31,691.07$2,718.58Savings

I don't have an opinion on the amount that makes it worth it.

I advise running several scenarios of nontaxable distributions vs. wages then analyzing those outcomes before making a decision.  Maybe consider 2024 and 2025 if possible.

And, as someone noted earlier, there are impacts on Social Security for different wage amounts. 

It's complicated right, but I think the timing principle is a big consideration:  Does the client save taxes now (and take advantage of that savings with investing it prudently) in order to defer taxes much later?

22K of home expenses deducted!  How is an S Corp accountable plan able to deduct 22K but a Sole Proprietorship can't deduct 22K?  

qbteachmt
Level 15

"How is an S Corp accountable plan able to deduct 22K but a Sole Proprietorship can't deduct 22K?"

It's the other way around. As an employee, there are no home office deductions any longer. There would need to be some authentication for that high of a reimbursable expense under an accountable plan, and the activity alone might not even qualify. Example: a sports referee doesn't work at home.

*******************************
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
TaxGuyBill
Level 15

@ptax255 wrote:

Updated based on everyone's feedback. Thanks! Curious, what amount do you all think it's worth all the extra work of an S corp?

 

 

That is something the client needs to decide.  Things to inform the client:

  • Tax saved.

Versus

  • Extra cost of income tax preparation.
  • Extra time/cost for bookkeeping.
  • Extra cost of payroll processing, payroll returns, year-end payroll stuff, etc.
  • Extra cost of unemployment.
  • Amount of reduced potential Social Security benefits.  In my opinion, if a tax preparer does not discuss this with the client they should NOT be recommending an S-corporation because the client would usually be mislead by only telling them of the tax savings (and potentially set up the tax preparer for a lawsuit for under-informing the client).