I think @TaxGuyBill  told me Ive been doing it wrong...but that allocation box I enter the SSN of the taxpayer on THAT return that is sharing it with someone else, along with their percentages being reported on that tax return...I do the same for each other persons return. 

Im not sure how you would input sharing with more than 1 SSN like youre trying to do, youd have to use 2 different 1095A forms but that would double everything up....so I dunno whats right.