Thank you.  Home state is KY.  AZ shows no state taxes but plenty of income for state to have deducted. I looked and found the AZ income tax rate is 2.5% so I am pretty sure he has to pay.  The 3 W-2's from other states (not KY) do not add up to the state taxes paid on the KY W2 under state taxes.  Even the one W-2 from KY shows ALL the income in KY, even though the other 3 show income in their states that add to the one total.  Not sure if I am missing something. 

Thanks for any help,

Barby