Good point. If it doesn't qualify, it doesn't. But if it does, the IRS wants us to attach a statement outlining why it isn't taxable. Therefore, our tax software should enable us to attach said statement, and print a line on the form that says "see statement."

The question at hand is "How does ProSeries allow us to report stuff like this to the IRS?"

The question is not, "Is a minister's pension taxable or not." 

I'm not sure your post is really answering the right question here?