Hi @bwcpa Thanks for posting in the Community about the calculation challenge that was submitted. We know it is frustrating when the challenge is closed and nothing is looked at. We have a Support article that has everything that needs to be submitted for a calculation challenge to be considered. 

How to challenge a calculation in Lacerte

There is a Before you start section and if the items in this section are not included Support will close the calculation challenge due to being incomplete. We just wanted to make sure that you knew so in the future this will not happen again.