"The All-Star badge was awarded to anyone who was an All-Star in the Accountants Community."

So it's an historic recognition of something that no longer applies? "Back in the olden days, when we were the Accountants Community, why I remember the youngens needin' help with their homework..." As in, none of the current users will understand its meaning, even if anyone even looks at Profiles, and none of us cares, because that designation is moot. But hey, thanks for throwing that bone. It gives me something to gnaw on.