Try relicensing the program. 

I can't give specifics as I use Lacerte, but a PS user might stop by with details.

@Just-Lisa-Now-  paging Lisa 😉

edit, found this from Lisa in another thread

Assuming you have a current 2023 ProSeries license, you'll want to Relicense your prior year programs so that they recognize it.

Tools > License Products

Sounds like you installed Professional by mistake so its wanting you to Pay Per Return.  If your toolbar looks like this, youre using Professional