ProSeries Professional.  Profile tab is where I need to indicate paper return filing.

ProSeries Professional doesn't have any "tabs" and nothing titled Profile, so Im honestly not sure what you're referring to.  ProSeries Basic might have tabs, but Ive never used it, so Im not sure.

For a paper filed return, just don't mark the EFile boxes on the Federal information worksheet.   Then be sure you fill out the 8948 and attach to the paper filed return showing the reason why, you're not Efiling.